MUMBAI – MAHARASHTRA – INDIA NOVEMBER 05 , 2012 01.00 A.M.
In recently held Mumbai Literary Festival , Sir Vidiadhar Surajprasad Naipaul a.k.a. Sir V. S. Naipaul got Lifetime Achievement Award . And then in the same festival he was attacked by Mr. Girish Karnad for being a right – winger and for propagating a skewed interpretation of Indian History . According to Mr. Karnad , Sir Vidia’s view of history is biased , twisted and un Indian .
It was shocking and totally unwarranted . Mr. Girish Karnad was invited to speak on his life in theatre . Instead , he went off – topic and criticised Sir Vidia S. Naipaul for being anti muslim . According to Girish Karnad , Sir Vidia is blind to architecture and deaf to music . For being blind to architecture , he quoted Sir Vidia , ” …….. Taj Mahal conjured the toil , sweat and blood that had gone into this vain construction , a monument to death and the memory of a tyrant . “
If this is the cause of lampooning Sir Vidia , then what is Mr. Girish Karnad’s opinion about Sahir Ludhianvi ? Sahir , a Urdu literary figure , wrote a very disparaging nazm about Taj Mahal . I am quoting the nazm with the help of my fading memory .
ताज तेरे लिए इक मजहर – ए – उल्फत ही सही ,
मुझ को इस वादी – ए – रंगीं से अकीदत ही सही ,
मेरी महबूब कहीं और मिला कर मुझ से ।
बज़्म – ए – शाही में ग़रीबों का गुज़र क्या मानी ,
सब्त जिस राह में हों सतवत – ए – शाही के निशाँ ,
उस पे उल्फत भरी रूहों का सफ़र क्या मानी ?
मेरी महबूब पस – ए - पर्दा – ए – तश्हीर – ए – वफ़ा ,
तूने सतवत के निशानों को तो देखा होता ,
मुर्दा शाहों के मकाबिर से बहलने वाली ,
अपने तारीक मकानों तो देखा होता ।
अनगिनत लोगों ने दुनिया में मुहब्बत की है ,
कौन कहता है कि सादिक न थे जज्बे उनके ,
लेकिन उन के लिए तश्हीर का सामान नहीं ,
क्योंकि वो लोग भी मेरी ही तरह मुफलिस थे ।
मेरी महबूब उन्हें भी तो मुहब्बत होगी ,
जिन की सन्नाई ने बख्शी है इसे शक्ल – ए – जमील ,
उन के प्यारों के मकाबिर रहे बे नाम – ओ – नुमूद
आज तक उन पे जलाई न किसी ने किंदील ।
ये चमनज़ार , ये जमना का किनारा , ये महल ,
ये मुनक्क़श दर – ओ – दीवार , ये मेहराब ये ताक़ ,
इक शहंशाह ने दौलत का सहारा ले कर ,
हम ग़रीबों की मुहब्बत का उड़ाया है मज़ाक़ ।।
Sahir was a known left – winger and himself a muslim . And he was more strident in criticising Taj Mahal . Mr. Karnad never felt any need to condemn Sahir . But he fired his salvos towards Sir Vidia . Therefore I am forced to believe that it is not for the love of Taj Mahal , but it is sheer jealousy and inferiority complex of Mr. Karnad . Or should I say , it is appeasement of worst order .
Mr. Karnad’s another contention is that Sir Vidia is deaf to music . No one can deny the contribution of muslim singers and musicians in the field of classical music . But along with many muslim classical singers , there are others also like ; Pandit Ravi Shankar , Pandit Hari Prasad Chaurasia , Pandit Shiv Kumar Sharma , Pandit Panna Lal Ghosh , Pandit Jasraj , Pandit Onkar Nath Thakur , Pandit Bhimsen Joshi , Kishori Amonkar , Shobha Gurtu , Rajan Mishra , Sajan Mishra , Jagjit Singh and above all the etherial Lata Mangeshkar and M. S. Subbulakshmi .
If I appreciate the above mentioned singers and artistes , I can’t automatically become a right – winger or a chauvinist or a Muslim – hater .
I denounce Mr. Girish Karnad for being a left – winger . I denounce him for being anti national . I denounce him for being a pseudo – secular and crypto – marxist . I denounce him for being anti – Hindu , and that too unnecessarily . He is himself an okay writer and a third – rate actor . All his Hindi films are testimony to this contention . It is sheer jealousy that he criticized a Nobel Laureate Sir Vidiadhar Surajprasad Naipaul .
He should know that his leftist leaning is exposed . His bias and appeasement is now known to all . His pseudo – secular credentials are condemned .
On behalf of me and my Acting Institute Vidur’s Kreating Charakters , I denounce him in strongest terms .
Shame on you Mr. Karnad !
MUMBAI – MAHARASHTRA – INDIA
- VS Naipaul slammed by Girish Karnad for his views on Muslims (ndtv.com)
- ‘Naipaul ,Tone Deaf’ Girish Karnad Video. He is Right (ramanan50.wordpress.com)
- I have no regrets for publicly targeting VS Naipaul: Girish Karnad (ibnlive.in.com)
- Karnad attacks Naipaul for his views on Muslims (ibnlive.in.com)
- LitFest director slams Karnad for targeting Naipaul (thehindu.com)
- After Girish Karnad, Taslima Nasreen rips into V S Naipaul (kractivist.wordpress.com)
- Naipaul is tone-deaf, anti-Muslim: Girish Karnad (ibnlive.in.com)
- Why is Naipaul Being Honoured?: Girish Karnad (kafila.org)
- Girish Karnad supports dalit protest singers (kabirkalamanch.wordpress.com)
- In continuing fake controversies, Naipaul V. Karnad (southasia.typepad.com)
Filed under: Denunciation Tagged: | Acting Institute, Acting Trainer, Crypto Marxist, Denunciation, Diction Trainer, Film, Girish Karnad, Hindi Teacher, History of India, India, Indian History, Jagjit Singh, Kamal Nayan Chaturvedi, Karnad, Koshori Amonkar, Lata Mangeshkar, Left Winger, M. S. Subbulakshmi, Maharashtra, MUMBAI - MAHARASHTRA - INDIA, Mumbai Lit -Fest, Mumbai Literary Festival, Nobel Laureate, Pandit Bhimsen Joshi, Pandit Hari Prasad Chaurasia, Pandit Jasraj, Pandit Omkar Nath Thakur, Pandit Panna Lal Ghosh, Pandit Ravi Shankar, Pandit Shiv Kumar Sharma, Pseudo Secular, Rajan Mishra, Right Winger, Sahir Ludhianvi, Sajan Mishra, Shobha Gurtu, Sir Vidia, Taj Mahal, Vidia, Vidiadhar Surajprasad Naipaul, Vidur, Vidur Chaturvedi, Vidur on Twitter, Vidur's Blog, Vidur's Kreating Charakters, VS Naipaul